March 4, 2024

Social Media Followers aren't Loyalty

Two happy woman after shopping

Loyalty through engagement on social media can be challenging for brands for several reasons. While social media platforms provide valuable metrics like likes, shares, and comments, these metrics reflect the top of the funnel and may not provide a complete picture of customer loyalty. 

Engagement on social media can be influenced by various factors, such as the timing of posts, trending topics, or even the use of paid advertising.

With the average customer retention rate in e-commerce around 38%, meaning just three out of 10 customers stick with one brand for over a year, e-commerce brands must rethink their post-purchase engagement strategy.

To truly understand and measure Loyalty, brands should aim to bring the conversation to their domain through a brand-owned customer network. By doing so, brands can create a more personalized and controlled environment to tailor experiences specific to individual customers. This shift allows brands to gather more in-depth data, such as user behavior, preferences, and interactions, which are crucial for accurately measuring and nurturing customer loyalty.

Bringing the conversation to their domain also enables brands to build a direct relationship with their audience, free from the distractions and limitations of social media algorithms. This direct interaction fosters deeper connections, enhances brand loyalty, and accurately measures customer engagement and Loyalty over time.

In summary, while social media engagement provides valuable insights, brands can effectively measure Loyalty by bringing the conversation to their domain, where they have more control over the customer experience and can gather richer data to assess and improve customer loyalty effectively.

Are you ready?

Transform your retention marketing and drive growth.
Learn How
LinkedInEmail
Related Blog

You may also read

Cost of a one-time customer
July 8, 2025
What Is a One-Time Customer Really Worth to Your Brand?
Learn the real value of a one-time customer in e-commerce. See how acquisition costs, low return rates, and retention strategies impact customer lifetime value and profitability.
Read More
Learn More
Ulta + VaynerMedia Is a Smart Play
June 25, 2025
Ulta + VaynerMedia Is a Smart Play. Here's How to Maximize the Momentum.
Ulta’s partnership with VaynerMedia is a masterclass in modern brand building. It’s fast, culturally fluent, and creatively fearless. But even the best campaigns are just the beginning. With Cohora, brands like Ulta can take that momentum and build something even more powerful, lasting customer relationships that fuel loyalty, advocacy, and long-term growth.
Read More
Learn More
May 28, 2025
The Loyalty Program You Designed in 2018 Is Failing You
Customers today expect more than discounts in exchange for their data. They want to feel seen, appreciated, and valued beyond the transaction. That means exclusive experiences, personalized perks, and content that actually feels… well, human. They don’t just want points. They want connection. And connection isn’t scalable if your loyalty system is stuck in the past.
Read More
Learn More